I was reading an interesting discussion yesterday on xquery-talk, replacing a node in in-memory XML.
How can one modify an XML structure through XQuery? In the future, the answer is definitely XQuery Update Facility. But the XQuery Update Facility is currently still work in progress, and not yet widely supported. What do we do today?
Ryan Grimm wrote an XQuery library to update an in-memory XML structure. And it looks like the in-mem-update library is pretty functional complete, having the following functions.
- node-insert-child
- node-insert-before
- node-insert-after
- node-replace
- node-delete
How do you use these functions? Let's have a look at a query from the XQuery Update Facility Use Cases, and show an equivalent implementation based on the in-mem-update library.
Consider Q2, Enter a bid for user Annabel Lee on February 1st, 1999 for 60 dollars on item 1001. The XQuery Update Facility based solution is as follows,
[cc lang="xquery"]let $uid := doc("users.xml")/users/user_tuple[name="Annabel Lee"]/userid return do insert
{data($uid)} 1001 60 1999-02-01
into doc("bids.xml")/bids [/cc]
Using the library we end up doing something as follows,[cc lang="xquery"]import module namespace mem = "http://xqdev.com/in-mem-update" at "in-mem-update.xqy"; let $uid := doc("users.xml")/users/user_tuple[name="Annabel Lee"]/userid return mem:node-insert-child( doc("bids.xml")/bids,
{data($uid)}
1001
60
1999-02-01
)[/cc]Looks pretty similar, no? There is actually one fundamental difference. With the XQuery Update Facility, the bids.xml document is actually updated. The in-mem-update variant, doesn't update the bids.xml document, but rather returns a copy of the original document reflecting the change.
This shows one of the possible issues with the library. Each modification made to an XML structure results in a copy. Making a lot of changes to a single XML structure, or updating a huge XML structure might affect performance. Still, I believe the library is useful in a lot of common scenarios.
The library is written to be used with MarkLogic Server, and unfortunately based on an older version of the XQuery specification. This makes it fail out of the box using XQuery 1.0 compliant processors. I updated the XQuery module in order to make it XQuery 1.0 compatible, and in addition added support for document nodes. It's available for download here.
So, you can now update all your data with DataDirect XQuery. Using the ddtek:sql-insert, ddtek:sql-update and ddtek:sql-delete functions you can update your relation database. And using the in-mem-update library you can now also make changes to your XML documents.
I believe this library is complementary to the functions modifying XML elements and attributes available in the FunctX XQuery library. Wouldn't it be cool to have these functions added to FunctX? I leave it to Ryan Grimm and Priscilla Walmsley to discuss this in detail.
digg_skin = 'compact'; digg_url = 'http://www.xml-connection.com/2007/11/updating-xml-with-xquery-10.html';